Search for Maybelline’s Sky High mascara and you’ll quickly notice there are two products with almost the same name: a washable version and a waterproof one. Most of what’s written about Sky High, including the raving reviews, doesn’t tell you which version it’s talking about, and it matters, because the two are built differently and come off your lashes in very different ways. For the broader story of the formula that went viral, see our full review of the original Sky High mascara.
Quick Verdict about Maybelline lash sensational sky high waterproof mascara
- Good fit if: you want a lengthening, volumizing waterproof mascara at a drugstore price, and you’re willing to use a proper remover at night.
- Think twice if: you want a mascara that comes off with water or micellar water, you have very sensitive or reactive eyes, or you wear lash extensions.
- Biggest strength in reviews: it holds up through the day without smudging or clumping, according to many reviewers.
- Biggest complaint in reviews: it’s harder to remove than most mascaras, and a minority of buyers report clumping or irritation.
What It Is, According to Maybelline
Maybelline describes Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof as a lengthening and volumizing mascara that delivers full volume and “limitless length.” Its main claims:
- Flex Tower brush. A spiral brush that bends to reach each lash from root to tip. Maybelline’s UK site describes the brush on the Sky High line as using a mix of half and full bristles to help separate lashes and reduce clumping.
- Bamboo extract and fibers. The formula is “infused” with them for a lightweight feel, and the waterproof copy says the result doesn’t flake or smudge.
- Sensitive-eye positioning. It’s labeled ophthalmologist tested and allergy tested, and suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Retailer pages also tag it fragrance-free, dermatologist tested, and non-comedogenic.
- Removal: with a waterproof eye makeup remover.
These are manufacturer claims. “Tested” means the brand ran tests, not that nobody will react to it.
Waterproof vs. Washable: The Differences That Matter
| Sky High Waterproof | Sky High Washable | |
|---|---|---|
| First ingredients | Isododecane (a lightweight solvent), beeswax, carnauba wax, disteardimonium hectorite, then water | Water, propylene glycol, acrylates polymer, polyurethane-35, beeswax |
| Removal | Waterproof or oil-based remover | Micellar water or a gentle eye makeup remover |
| Shades (US retailers) | Very Black and Brownish Black | Nine shades, including Blackest Black and Very Black |
| List price | $13.99 | $13.99 |
| Size | 0.24 fl oz per Maybelline’s specs (some retailers round to 0.2) | 0.24 fl oz |
| Best for | Humid days, swimming, watery eyes, long events | Everyday wear when you want an easy cleanup |
Two points explain most of the difference. First, a water-based formula like the washable version dissolves in water, while the waterproof version leads with a solvent and waxes that resist it. That’s why waterproof mascara needs a dedicated remover. Second, the waterproof version comes in only two shades at US retailers, so if you want a color or a softer brown-black, the washable range gives you more choice.
What’s in It (and What to Watch For)
Here’s the ingredient list shown on retailer pages, with notes. Lists can vary by shade and market, so check your tube.
- Isododecane, waxes (beeswax, carnauba, rice bran, synthetic beeswax), and film-formers: these build the waterproof, long-wearing coating.
- Rayon: the “fibers” that add length.
- Bamboo (Bambusa vulgaris) extract: it appears near the end of the list, which usually signals a small amount. Treat it as a marketing note rather than the main reason this mascara performs.
- Hydrogenated jojoba oil and caprylic/capric triglyceride: conditioning emollients. Some retailer pages tag the mascara “oil-free,” so if you avoid oils for a specific reason, read the label instead of relying on the tag.
- Alcohol denat., talc, BHT, and titanium dioxide: common in mascaras, but worth knowing if you’re avoiding any of them.
- Beeswax and possibly carmine: the colorant list includes carmine (CI 75470), an insect-derived pigment, and the formula contains beeswax, so it isn’t vegan.
- Safety note: at least one retailer lists “Flammable until dry,” which is common for solvent-based formulas. Let it dry before going near heat or flames, and keep it away from cigarettes.
If you have an allergy, a sensitivity, or an eye condition, talk to an eye doctor instead of relying on this summary.
Shades and Size: Clearing Up the Confusion
- Shades: US retailers list the waterproof version in Very Black (802) and Brownish Black. Some Maybelline copy mentions “Very Black and Blackest Black,” so match the shade name and number on the box to what you want. Maybelline also releases seasonal Sky High waterproof shades from time to time.
- Size: Retailer listings show waterproof tubes as 0.2 fl oz while Maybelline’s specs for the line say 0.24 fl oz (7.2 ml). The difference looks like rounding, and Walmart’s price per ounce is calculated on 0.24. The same size applies to the washable version.
What It Costs
The list price is $13.99, but you’ll often pay less. Here’s what I found, with price per ounce calculated on 0.24 fl oz:
| Retailer | Price | Per fl oz |
|---|---|---|
| Maybelline / Ulta / Walgreens (list) | $13.99 | about $58.29 |
| Ulta (sale price seen) | $13.29 | about $55.38 |
| Walmart | $10.82 | about $45.08 |
| H-E-B | $9.98 | about $41.58 |
Prices vary by store, and in-store prices may differ from online. One older Walmart snapshot also listed third-party sellers starting around $19.95, so buying from the retailer directly usually costs less than a marketplace reseller.
What Reviewers Say
On Ulta, the waterproof product page showed 4.5 out of 5 from roughly 11,900 reviews, and a Walgreens listing showed 4.6 from about 13,900. One caution: Maybelline notes that its Sky High ratings include all washable and waterproof shades from retailers worldwide, so those numbers describe the whole Sky High family, not only the waterproof version. Treat the scores as a general sign of popularity.
What reviewers praise:
- It stays put and doesn’t smudge or transfer, including in long days or heat.
- It gives length and volume without much clumping, in many reviews.
- The price is considered fair for the performance, with some comparing it favorably to mascaras that cost $30 or more.
What reviewers complain about:
- Removal. Several reviewers say the waterproof version is hard to remove without a waterproof remover or an oil cleanser.
- Clumping or drying out. Some say a tube turned clumpy or dry, and one reviewer noted a tube seemed dry on arrival.
- Irritation. A small number report an irritated lash line, though others find it fine for sensitive eyes.
- Lash fallout. One reviewer wondered whether lash loss came from curling or the difficult removal. That’s a reminder that how you remove waterproof mascara matters.
How to Apply It
Maybelline’s directions are simple: hold the flexible brush against your lashes, extend it from root to tip, and repeat until you have the volume and length you want. A few habits help with a waterproof formula:
- Start with clean, dry lashes. Oily residue can interfere with grip.
- Curl first if you like, then apply. Curling before mascara is a common routine.
- Don’t pump the wand. Pumping pushes air into the tube and can dry it out faster.
- Build coats while the first is still slightly tacky. Waterproof formulas can set quickly, and layering on a dry coat can cause clumps.
- Let it dry before you blink repeatedly or touch your face.
- Skip heavy, oily eye creams right under the lash line, since oils can break down a waterproof formula over the day.
If you have hooded eyes and mascara keeps transferring onto your lid, a waterproof formula is a sensible choice, and our guide to eyeliner for hooded eyes explains why blinking transfers product and how to reduce it.
How to Remove Waterproof Mascara Without Tugging
This is the step that decides whether you like this mascara. Maybelline’s own guidance for its waterproof Sky High says to use a waterproof eye makeup remover or a bi-phase, oil-based remover. Its instructions for the mascara are specific:
- Put the remover on a cotton pad.
- Hold the pad against your closed lashes for several seconds so the formula can break down.
- Gently wipe downward, without rubbing.
If a cleansing balm or oil cleanser is already in your routine, it can dissolve waterproof mascara too. Our roundup of cleansing balms worth trying covers options that make this step faster. Whatever method you use, patience beats scrubbing, and rubbing or pulling at lashes is the habit to avoid.
Lash extensions and lifts: Maybelline’s FAQ says the waterproof formula can be worn over a fresh lash lift, but oil-based removers can break down some extension adhesives, so check with your lash technician first.
Who Should and Shouldn’t Buy It
Good fit if:
- You want a waterproof mascara for humid days, swimming, travel, or events where tears are likely.
- You prefer a drugstore price.
- You don’t mind a two-step removal.
Think twice if:
- You want a mascara that comes off with water, in which case the washable version, or a tubing mascara, is simpler. Our guide to tubing mascara explains how those formulas come off with warm water.
- You wear extensions and your technician advises against oil-based removers.
- You have a known sensitivity to any ingredient in the list above.
- You want a vegan formula.
Alternatives to Compare
- Same brand, washable: the washable Sky High, covered in our main Sky High review, if easy removal matters more than waterproofing.
- Same brand, different formula: our look at Maybelline’s waterproof Body mascara covers a different Lash Sensational waterproof option.
- More options: our roundups of the best waterproof mascaras and drugstore mascara picks compare other formulas at similar prices.
- Prestige route: if you’re curious how a luxury formula compares, our review of Chanel mascara covers that end of the market.
Safety and How Long It Lasts
Eye doctors commonly recommend replacing mascara about every three months, including the American Academy of Ophthalmology, because bacteria can build up in the tube. Don’t share mascara, don’t use it if your eyes are infected, and stop using it if you notice irritation, redness, or discharge. See a doctor if symptoms persist.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the difference between Sky High Waterproof and Sky High Washable?
The waterproof version is built on a solvent and wax base that resists water and needs a waterproof or oil-based remover. The washable version is water-based and comes off with micellar water or a gentle remover. The waterproof one also comes in fewer shades.
How much does Maybelline Sky High Waterproof cost?
The list price is $13.99. Retailers such as Walmart and H-E-B showed lower prices, around $10.82 and $9.98.
What shades does it come in?
US retailers list Very Black and Brownish Black. Always match the shade name and number on the box.
How do you remove Sky High Waterproof mascara?
Use a waterproof or oil-based eye makeup remover on a cotton pad, hold it on closed lashes for several seconds, and wipe downward without rubbing. A cleansing balm or oil cleanser can also work.
Is it safe for sensitive eyes and contact lenses?
Maybelline says it’s ophthalmologist tested and suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, but reactions vary, and a few reviewers report irritation. Stop using it if your eyes become irritated.
Is it vegan?
No. The formula contains beeswax, and the colorant list includes carmine.
Can I wear it with lash extensions?
Maybelline says the waterproof formula can be worn over a fresh lash lift, but oil-based removers can break down some extension adhesives, so ask your lash technician first.
Is it really waterproof?
It’s designed to resist water, sweat, and tears. Oily eyelids or oil-based products near the lash line can reduce wear for some people.
How long does a tube last?
Plan to replace it about every three months for hygiene, even if there’s product left.
